Alternative Title: Troubleshooting with Ice Cream
Monday, April 6, 2015
This
week was a bit of a mess as far as ice cream went.
If you checked my
Upcoming
and Past Flavors page, you’ll have seen that I was supposed to do a Mango
Ice Cream.
Unfortunately, the price of
mangoes doubled by the time I went to buy them, and I didn’t want to pay $2.49
per mango.
That seemed outrageous.
But, being the brilliant fellow that I am, I
didn’t discover this until Saturday evening which basically meant that if I
wanted to stay on track ice cream-wise I had to find a new recipe
tonight.
And I did.
It was Pink Panther
Ice Cream from
Scoop Adventures: The Best Ice Cream of the
50 States by Lindsay
Clendaniel of
Scoop Adventures.
Pink
Panther Ice Cream seemed like a lovely recipe and a wonderful addition to our
Easter spread the next day. It had
plenty of fruit, a dash of alcohol, and a beautiful shade. Unfortunately, it also had crème de cassis: black currant liquor.
Do
you have any idea how hard it is to find crème
de cassis on a Saturday night in Kentucky?
No one knows what it is, not even people who have worked with alcohol
their entire lives. Grocery stores don’t
carry it, and local liquor stores don’t carry it. I suppose that’s why God invented Liquor
Barns, the end result of a bunch of rednecks shooting down a spaceship and
filling it with alcohol. But bless them
because Liquor Barn had one bottle of crème
de cassis.
Unfortunately,
that was not the end of my ice cream woes.
I’m not fully satisfied with this recipe.
Like my
Margarita
Ice Cream recipe some time ago, it leaves a sort of waxy, filmy taste on
the back of your tongue.
Initially, I’d
thought the powdered sugar in the Margarita Ice Cream had done that, but Pink
Panther Ice Cream doesn’t
have any
powdered sugar in it.
So what could the
problem be?
Butterfat.
Thanks
to the wonderful people at
Ice Cream
Geek, I’ve learned that one of the biggest factors in an ice cream’s
texture is the amount of butterfat (the fatty part of the milk) that’s in it
and that when you have too much butterfat, it leaves a weird, waxy taste on the
back of your tongue.
The author of the
article
“Butterfat and Ice Cream”
was also kind enough to create an
Ice Cream Butterfat Calculator
for public use.
How much butterfat does
this Pink Panther Ice Cream Recipe have?
19%, quite a bit above the 10% -- 16% that ice cream usually has (And
for your information, Margarita Ice Cream has 28.9% butterfat – no wonder I
couldn’t get rid of that waxy taste!).
There
are a few things I can do to change this, the easiest being switching
ingredients. Whole milk only has 3.5%
butterfat so switching around the proportions of heavy whipping cream and whole
milk should give me less butterfat but still maintain the taste and
texture. However, in doing so I might
create a lot of ice crystals since this recipe only uses milk and heavy
whipping cream as emulsifiers – and comes with alcohol, which makes it harder
to freeze, as well as fruit, which is naturally icy. Perfecting this recipe will probably take
quite a bit of trial and error.
However,
its butterfat content wasn’t the last of my issues with this recipe. I personally thought the dairy component
overwhelmed the somewhat delicate fruity flavors and diminished the ice cream’s
refreshing quality. By the time it was
churned, the black currant, raspberry, and orange flavors were almost
nonexistent – mere aftertastes. In the
future, I’d like to add more orange zest and steep it longer as well as add
some raspberry extract to really bring out the flavor. I’d also like to try this recipe as a sorbet
or sherbet, though I have no idea if it’s even possible to make a decent
alcoholic sorbet/sherbet. And yet, as
summer nears I have the feeling that I’m going to find out.
Until
then, here is the Pink Panther Ice Cream recipe I used.
Ingredients
- 6
oz fresh raspberries
- 1
tbsp orange juice concentrate
- 1
¾ cups heavy cream
- 1
¼ cups whole milk
- Pinch
of salt
- 1
tsp orange zest
- 2
½ tbsp crème de cassis
* Note: you might try 1 ¼ cups heavy cream and 1 ¾ cups whole
milk. That will bring it down to the
more acceptable 14.3%.
Directions
- Place
the raspberries in a blender and puree until smooth.
- Strain
the puree through a fine-mesh sieve to remove the seeds.
- In
a medium bowl, combine the raspberry puree with the orange juice
concentrate. Cover and set aside.
- Combine
the cream, milk, sugar, salt, and orange zest in a medium saucepan. Place over medium heat and bring the milk
mixture to a low boil. Cook until the
sugar dissolves – 3 minutes.
- Remove
from the heat and pour through a sieve into the raspberry-orange juice
mixture. Cool to room temperature. Cover and refrigerate until chilled – at
least 4 hours.
- Once
chilled, pour the ice cream base into an ice cream maker and churn according to
the manufacturer’s instructions. When
it’s almost churned, add the cassis
(Doing so at the end means that your ice cream will actually freeze.).
- Once
churned, transfer to a freezer-safe container and freeze until firm – at least
4 hours.

As I
said above, the end result left a lot to be desired, and the churning process
really diminished the fruit flavors.
The
resulting flavor smelled heavily of oranges and started out tart but was
quickly overwhelmed by dairy – kind of like a weak, frozen Orange Julius.
The texture was good though a bit melty
(alcohol, you know) and set nicely into a medium firmness.
And, despite my misgivings about this recipe,
I wouldn’t necessarily tell people not to try it.
It’s a really pretty lavender-pink, smells
delightful, and could be excellent on a summer’s day in a sugar cone.
Just maybe tweak the whipping cream-milk
ratio, okay?
You’ll be glad you did.
Overview
- Base
prep time: 20 – 30 minutes
- Base
chill time: at least 4 hours
- Ice
cream set time: at least 4 hours
- Taste:
initially tart with strong notes of orange and subtle ones of raspberry and
black currant – flavor is quickly overpowered by heavy cream and butterfat
- Difficulty
level: medium
- Expense
level: low to medium
- Makes:
4 cups (1 quart)